6 Essential Steps to Hiring the Right Roofing Contractor — From Covered Exteriors

Hiring the right roofing contractor can feel overwhelming—especially when the stakes are so high. Your roof protects your home, your belongings, and your peace of mind. Choosing the wrong company could leave you with costly headaches and major regrets.

At Covered Exteriors, we believe homeowners should feel empowered and informed, not pressured or confused. That’s why we put together this simple guide to help you confidently hire a roofer you can trust.

Follow these 6 steps to make the right decision the first time.

Step 1: Start by Researching Local Roofing Companies

The first step is to focus on companies that are local, established, and trusted in your area.

Check their Google listing, website, and online reviews. Look for companies with recent positive feedback, clear business addresses, and proven experience with roofing projects in your state.

Why it matters:
Local contractors understand your area’s building codes, weather patterns, and permitting requirements—and they’ll still be around if you ever need warranty service.

At Covered Exteriors, we're proud to serve homeowners across New Jersey with a consistent record of excellence.

Step 2: Verify Their Credentials and Insurance

Before you meet with anyone, ask for proof of the following:

• State roofing license

• General liability insurance

• Workers’ compensation coverage

• Bonding (if required in your state)

A legitimate roofing contractor will be happy to provide this information—no hesitation, no excuses.

Why it matters:
Verifying credentials protects you legally and financially if something unexpected happens during your project.

Covered Exteriors is fully licensed, insured, and bonded for your complete protection.

Step 3: Get Detailed Written Estimates (and Compare Apples to Apples)

Always get your estimates in writing, and make sure they include:

• A full breakdown of materials and labor

• The type and brand of roofing materials being used

• Timeline for project completion

• Warranty details

• Payment terms

Be wary of vague or one-page quotes with just a lump sum. Without a line-by-line breakdown, it's impossible to know what you’re actually getting—and where contractors might cut corners.

Pro tip:
Price matters, but it shouldn't be your only deciding factor. Always compare the scope of work and the quality of products before choosing based on price alone.

At Covered Exteriors, our estimates are clear, transparent, and easy to understand—no hidden surprises.

Step 4: Ask About Warranties—Both Manufacturer and Workmanship

When evaluating a roofer, ask about two separate warranties:

• Manufacturer Warranty: Protects against defects in the roofing materials.

• Workmanship Warranty: Covers installation errors or labor issues.

A reputable company stands behind both. Look for a workmanship warranty of at least 10 years—and preferably longer.

Why it matters:
Most roofing issues are due to poor installation, not faulty materials. You want a contractor who’ll fix any problems, not leave you stranded.

Covered Exteriors proudly offers some of the strongest workmanship warranties in the industry, because quality matters.

Step 5: Interview the Contractor Before Signing Anything

Take time to sit down (or schedule a call) with the contractor and ask questions like:

• Who will actually be installing my roof—your crew or subcontractors?

• What steps will you take to protect my property during the project?

• How will you handle permits and inspections?

• Can I see examples of your recent work?

• What’s your process if something unexpected comes up during the job?

A trustworthy contractor will welcome your questions and answer them clearly.

At Covered Exteriors, we believe an informed homeowner is a happy homeowner—so we walk you through everything before moving forward.

Step 6: Trust Your Instincts (and Don’t Be Rushed)

Finally, trust your gut.

If something feels off—if you feel pressured, confused, or unsure—it’s okay to walk away. Roofing is a major investment, and the right contractor will respect your need to make an informed decision without high-pressure tactics.

The best companies earn your trust through communication, professionalism, and transparency—not pushy sales games.

When you choose Covered Exteriors, you’ll experience a different kind of roofing company—one that puts your needs first and stands behind our promises.

Ready to Start Your Roofing Project the Right Way?

Choosing the right contractor is the most important decision you’ll make for your home’s protection.

At Covered Exteriors, we make the process easy, transparent, and stress-free—from the very first conversation to the final inspection.

• Free, no-pressure consultations

• Clear and detailed estimates

• Best-in-class workmanship warranties

• Local, professional crews

• Customer service that actually cares

Call (929) 888-7374 or visit CoveredExteriors.com today to schedule your free consultation.

Covered Exteriors: Protecting your home—and your trust—one roof at a time.